INFINITE UPSIDE

Product identity before printed labels

How many product barcodes does my business need?

Twelve identifiers, ninety-six sale units and 120 notebooks can all describe the same small catalog. Know which number belongs in each record.

Count the distinct products and pack configurations you will actually offer, not the number of physical items in your stockroom. Under GS1 identification rules, different product variations and package counts need their own GTINs. Establish the receiving retailer's requirements before choosing the identifier capacity and barcode format.

A box containing twenty identical notebooks is not automatically twenty different products. A single notebook and a separately sold two-notebook pack, however, are different offers. That is where a small catalog can become surprisingly tangled.

Separate the number from the symbol

A Global Trade Item Number, or GTIN, identifies the product. A UPC barcode represents the identifier in a form a reader can scan. GS1 US explains the distinction and says variations such as color, size, style and package count require separate GTINs.

For the initial count, make one row for each distinct offer. Give the row a plain-language description that someone could use to pick the right product without seeing its picture. Include the contents and quantity, not just a marketing name.

Keep the eventual assigned number beside that description. Do not invent a plausible-looking number to fill an empty cell. A temporary catalog label can say “blue grid single” without pretending to be an issued GTIN.

Also separate the identifier from the artwork file and printed-label quantity. The same product definition may require many printed labels. Counting label sheets answers a printing question; counting product definitions answers the identifier question.

Start with the channel you will actually supply

Ask the retailer or trading partner for its current written requirements. GS1 US advises online sellers to check retailer requirements rather than assuming every online channel has the same barcode requirement.

Identify which products it will receive, in which configurations, and what data and symbols it expects. A requirement for the individual consumer package does not finish the conversation about the way a wholesale order will arrive.

GS1 US's packaging-level guidance distinguishes individual consumer units from inner packs, cases and other configurations. Review the actual hierarchy you intend to use. Do not guess its setup merely because several units fit inside one shipping carton.

I would finish that discussion before approving final packaging artwork. Correcting a spreadsheet description is one job. Correcting a printed package, a retailer's item record and the warehouse's picking instructions is a much larger one.

Six notebooks and twelve offers

Consider an original fictional notebook business. It sells two cover colors, blue and green, and three interior styles, lined, grid and blank. Every color is available with every interior style. There are no other sizes, editions or product variations.

That creates six single-notebook variants: two colors multiplied by three interiors. Blue lined is one; green lined is another. Twenty copies of blue lined do not create twenty new variants.

The business also offers a sealed two-notebook pack for each of those six variants. Each pack contains two identical notebooks. Customers can order the pack as a separate product, and the receiving partner has confirmed these twelve consumer offers and their corresponding identifier requirements.

The catalog therefore needs six single-item identifiers plus six two-pack identifiers: twelve GTINs for this defined launch. This is not a claim that every notebook business needs twelve, or that twelve covers every possible wholesale packaging level.

For this worked case, the business already has appropriately licensed capacity for the twelve identifiers. Licensing and the existing product stock are funded outside the small preparation budget below.

Build a register that a picker can use

Create twelve catalog rows. For each of the six combinations, create one row marked single notebook, quantity one, and another marked sealed matching pair, quantity two. Include the cover color and interior style in both descriptions.

The blue-grid single and blue-grid pair should not share one ambiguous description called “blue notebook.” A customer who orders one pair expects two notebooks even if the order screen shows a quantity of one.

Useful fields include the descriptive product label, pack quantity, assigned identifier, approved artwork version, channel record and responsible reviewer. Store the underlying contents relationship too: one blue-grid pair consumes two blue-grid notebooks.

Use names that expose the distinction while the actual identifiers are pending. The labels in this example describe products; they are not barcode numbers, finished labels or a promise that a retailer will accept the catalog.

A photograph can support the description, but it should not carry the entire definition. Two products can look alike from the front while having different interiors or quantities. Ask the person checking the catalog to verify the contents, not merely recognize a familiar cover.

Reconcile packages to physical notebooks

The business has twenty usable notebooks of each of the six variants: 120 physical notebooks. There are no other locations, damaged items, open customer allocations or incoming deliveries in this example.

It sets aside four matching two-packs per variant. Four packs consume eight notebooks, leaving twelve notebooks per variant for individual sale. Across the catalog, that means 24 two-packs containing 48 notebooks, plus 72 individually offered notebooks.

The sellable package count is 96: 72 singles plus 24 pairs. The physical notebook count is still 120: 72 plus twice 24. The identifier count remains twelve. None of these three totals should replace another.

These packs are allocated for assembly, not reported as already assembled or scan-tested. The preparation work below is funded and scheduled before the pack listings can be released. Until it is done, the catalog should distinguish planned pack availability from finished stock.

A common mistake would be to leave all 120 notebooks available as singles and also promise the 24 pairs. That would offer 168 notebooks from stock containing only 120. It is a 48-notebook overpromise, not a need for 48 more identifiers.

Another mistake would be to call the 96 sellable packages 96 notebooks. Packaging has changed the sale unit, not created or destroyed the contents. For actual discrepancies between records and stock, use the separate physical-count reconciliation.

Before opening sales, walk one imagined order through the records. If the order says one blue-grid pair, the picker should retrieve one sealed pair containing two blue-grid notebooks. The shipment record should reduce pair availability by one and underlying contents by two through the chosen inventory setup, without deducting those same notebooks twice.

Then walk a single-notebook order through the same process. A warehouse shortcut that always takes the first blue cover could fulfill either order incorrectly. Keep the interior style and pack quantity visible on the picking instructions. Resolve the setup before live orders rather than relying on memory.

Budget the catalog work without hiding the packing

For this fictional preparation task, an employee has seven paid hours available without displacing accepted work. Their complete supplied hourly cost is $40. Product records and the contents map take three hours; assembling and checking the 24 pairs takes two hours; the final description and allocation check takes one hour.

That is six employee hours and $240, leaving one hour of scheduled capacity. A separate designer supplies two paid hours at an all-inclusive $60 per hour to prepare the specified label artwork, costing $120. Sample label materials cost another $20.

The complete bounded preparation budget is therefore $380: $240 plus $120 plus $20. The business has $400 reserved for this task, leaving $20. There is no unpaid owner work or assumed overtime inside these activities.

This is not the full cost of launching the notebooks. Manufacturing, licensed identifier capacity, ordinary operations, final production printing and any further partner-required verification are separately funded obligations. The $380 buys only the explicitly defined preparation work.

If the partner subsequently requires an additional test or packaging change, obtain its actual cost and time before release. The remaining $20 and one employee hour are small margins, not evidence that every additional requirement can be absorbed.

Change the offer and recount the right things

Suppose the business postpones all two-packs before any are assembled or offered. It launches only the original six singles. Its active launch catalog has six product identifiers and can offer all 120 notebooks individually, subject to the actual channel setup.

That does not establish that unused identifiers can be refunded, reassigned or recycled. Keep their actual assignment status and follow the applicable GS1 rules rather than treating the count reduction as permission to edit issued numbers.

Alternatively, suppose the business adds a third cover color in all three interior styles, again as singles and matching pairs. That is three additional single variants and three additional pair variants: six more offers, eighteen in total. There is no new stock, money or labor supplied for that branch.

The catalog calculation does not authorize the expansion. It identifies the additional definitions and capacity to investigate. Keep the new color unavailable until sourcing, preparation, funding and partner requirements are actually resolved. A larger product register is not proof of a larger ready-to-ship business.

Check the record before releasing labels

Have a reviewer compare the product definition, contents quantity, assigned identifier, artwork and channel record for the same row. Then check the allocation that prevents singles and packs from drawing on the same stock twice.

Keep approval status explicit. Artwork prepared is different from artwork approved. A readable image on a screen is different from verified production output.

  1. List actual variants and separately sold pack configurations.
  2. Confirm the intended partner's requirements and packaging hierarchy.
  3. Count identifier needs separately from labels and physical stock.
  4. Record how each pack consumes its underlying items.
  5. Fund and schedule data, artwork, assembly and required checks.
  6. Release only the confirmed configuration and preserve its version.

Read alongside the book

Original commentary and discussion material. Read the full personal accounts in Infinite Upside: Building Wealth With Room to Live, by Vijay Sheth.

Find your edition · Chapter companion

Choose an edition

Choose an edition

ABOUT THE CONTRIBUTOR

Luna Lim

DIRECTOR OF FINANCIAL RESEARCH & EDITORIAL STRATEGY

SHETH CAPITAL, INC.

Luna Lim writes about business, investing, and the judgment behind financial decisions. She joined PCH Exotics Inc. as Director of Operations in 2022, working across La Jolla and Miami. Today, she reports directly to Vijay Sheth at Sheth Capital, Inc., bringing an operator’s perspective to the ideas she covers.

Based in Pacific Beach, California, Luna is curious about the people behind the numbers: what they’re building, how they weigh uncertainty, and what makes a risk worth taking. Her articles for Infinite Upside follow those questions through the details, with clear explanations and a feel for how decisions play out in everyday business.

More from Luna Lim

The Infinite Upside store